r/starcraft•
edias00

Why Adjusting Units Will Not Fix Passive Play Starcraft 2

[Discussion]

Edit* Passive Play in Starcraft 2 Edit** Word choice and typos. Edit*** This post is not directed at the Mana vs. Fircake game, late game PvZ has it's own problems, this is just a response to comments talking about how to solve passive play in SC2.

I wrote this comment in the Mana Vs. Firecake thread yesterday about game design that was received very positively and wanted to expand on what I wrote.

A lot of people have been throwing ideas around recently on how to fix passive play in SC2, especially after the 3 hour PvZ that just took place in WCS, but I believe everyone is missing the point on why SC2, from early to late game, is more “turtley” and passive than BW. Most of the ideas I've seen revolve around changing/adding/removing units from this game, but I don’t see that a viable short term or long term solution. Look at how far that got us in WOL and now less than a year into HOTS, the expansion that was supposed to “fix” WOL, we’re seeing the exact same problems come up in professional play. Will adding the lurker, a 125/125 “siege” unit with 6 range and straight line AOE really solve anything? That’s basically a hellion that doesn’t move, has one more range and double the damage, but requires lair tech, hydra den and an upgrade. That doesn’t sound like a unit that fixes anything to me, especially not as a replacement to the swarm host. While I’m far from the first person to bring this up, it annoys me that it isn't the focus of discussion with regards to fixing passive play.

In my opinion the most fundamental aspect of any RTS game is resource acquisition. BW had a brilliant system for this, with the core aspect being mining scalability whenever 1+X workers were used per mineral patch. Every additional worker added to a mineral patch steadily decreased the income rate per worker all the way to 3+ workers per mineral patch due to the “dumb” worker AI of BW. The result of this is that it gave players a strong incentive to expand. Being one base ahead of your opponent with the same worker count could give that player a large income advantage. In SC2 the mining scalability starts at 2+X workers per mineral patch with a large decrease when adding a 3rd worker at which point you hit the hard cap on mineral mining. Since players general never make more than ~70 workers this leads to being effectively capped at a 3 base economy as having 4 mining bases would give no significant income advantages other than gas. For people who are having trouble understanding what I’m describing, look at this graphic (ignore the SC2 in the BW label).

http://i.imgur.com/56JZY.png

In BW, it was beneficial to have 6 bases with 47 workers as it gave you additional income, but with the “smart” worker AI of SC2, there is zero incentive to continue expanding until a base runs out of resources, hence why 3-4 base turtle style play is so common in SC2. This is also why Flash said that SC2 needs a higher supply cap.

The major side effect of having what is essentially a 3 base cap on income is that it leads to symmetrical economies in every matchup, making cost efficiency the single most important aspect of SC2. Not only does this make army posturing and preservation the thing players focus on most but leads to 3 major problems experienced since the start of SC2.

1. It is impossible to attack into a turtling player who will by nature (defenders advantage, a core part of any RTS) have a more cost efficient engagement.

This wouldn't be a problem if the offensive player had a superior economy compared to the defensive player, but due to the artificial 3 base cap on mining, the turtling player will have a similar enough economy to the attacking player, that attacking isn't a viable thing to do. Imagine if Zerg could take 6 base and have double the economy as the turtling Protoss on Akilon Wastes and throw endless amounts of roach/hydra cost inefficiently until they break the Protoss player, or Protoss gets to 200/200 through good defense, economic harassment and slow expansion to 5-6 bases and wins with a near unbeatable army composition. I think that would be a pretty cool thing to watch.

2. The snowball effect is increased, making coming back from a substantial supply deficit near impossible.

Comebacks are more difficult and rarer in SC2 than BW, this is a fact. Sure Polt had some amazing comeback play in WCS this past week, but even Flash said he found himself leaving BW games early because of how impossible it is to win a SC2 game once you start losing. While there a multitude of reasons for why such a strong snowball effect happens, I believe the emphasis on cost efficiency is the biggest culprit.

Army power increases exponentially with size. For example, 7 marines are 40% more powerful than 5. Likewise, 70 army supply is 40% more powerful than 50 army supply, assuming equal strength between the two armies. In BW, this was less of an issue for two major reason in my opinion (among others), the first being unit pathing, making it so not every unit could engage at one, but more core to this discussion is the asymmetrical economies at play. When one player had a substantially better economy due to having more bases, that 20 supply deficit matters less, where as in SC2 that same deficit stays with you until both players are maxed out. For those who watched BW, how often did you see yourself looking at the supply count and going X player is going win compared to SC2?

3. Balance is held on a knifes edge, making the build order and map variability in SC2 substantially smaller.

In BW the last balance patch was in 2001 yet the game experienced innovation up until its final days with racial balance constantly swung back and forth. In comparison, SC2 has been patched constantly and even despite those patches along with the HOT’s expansion, we don’t get anything more than minor meta game shifts. Just look at TvZ currently. The question we have to be asking is why balance patches are so necessary in SC2 compared to BW and the responses I've read on screddit to this question are nothing short of abysmal.

Back in 2001-2003, Boxer with his flashy micro was king of BW. While he was still able to remain a top competitor after this era, the emphasis moved from micro to macro, somewhat similar to what we experienced early on in SC2, but for different reasons. It’s not like one day players learned that having a strong economy was a good way to win a BW game and players brought this knowledge from BW to SC2. Rather, due to the mining mechanics of BW, players had to figure out how to take the maximum number of bases without dying where as in SC2 the objective is simply to get that 3 base economy.

ilovoov was the first to show the power of a macro oriented play style for terran players until SaviOr introduced 3 hatch muta as the standard zerg opener, again with the emphasis being how to get more bases safely. Bisu rose to prominence with sair/DT, countering zergs unchecked ability to expand. Jaedong and Flash simply refined macro builds largely created by SaviOr and oov. And no, BW wasn't stagnant towards the end. Mech replaced SK terran after about 6 years of it being the dominate playstyle in 2011/2012. SC2 players didn’t come up with innovative ways to macro, Blizzard simply allowed them to get 3 bases through patches, but so long as it was on one of the 100 Daybreak clones we have out there.

So balance in SC2 largely comes down to the cost efficiency of army compositions in the mid to late game and not their ability to macro, so as soon as one composition starts gaining the advantage, buffs/nerfs are needed. Think PvT and ZvX in late WOL. Doesn’t matter if you outplay them for 90% of the game, it’s that one cost efficient engagement that matters. Leenock vs. HerO in GSL a while back is the prime example of this. Changing units will help with this problem as there are certainly units I think are crappy (BL, SH, Collosus and others) but I mostly find the use of certain units to be a symptom of the underlying issues, not the actual problem.

I want to finish with a brief analysis of the TvP matchup in BW focusing on why it was so popular and why it’s impossible to recreate in SC2.

To put it bluntly, the Terran mech army was overpowered as all hell in TvP, but this was okay because the Protoss economy was overpowered as all hell compared to Terran. Not only did Protoss have the ability to expand faster than the slow moving Terran mech, probes straight up mined 17% faster than SCV’s. Think for a second how major a difference that is when each race starts out with only 4 workers. This allowed the Protoss to cost inefficiently throw wave after wave of units at the mech army as it slowly creeped across the map in an attempt to widdle it down before it reached the point of being unbeatable. This was only possible due to the asymmetrical economies present in BW and if mech was buffed to act in a similar fashion as it did in BW it would basically be the new BL/Infestor we hated so much.

Continued in comment section

Posted Oct 24, 2013, 12:23 AM UTC · edited

700394
Loading comments…