Help with boy name

Choosing a girl name was so easy! Now a boy name is so hard!!!!!!!!!!!! I think we are getting there. I have 4 names: Theodore, William and Edward and Henry. Then I also liked Charles and James (not the meaning of the names so much). I like old and strong names. My favorite was Conrad but there is a huge potential of teasing in bilingual school. I was hesitant with Theodore with sister’s name is Eleanor (too Roosevelt?). If we choose Henry, Queen Eleanor was married to Henry, is that also raising eyebrows. Should we stay away from Henry?

Am I overthinking? Thank you