Presenting both I94 and I-797 documents upon re-entry?

Hi all, had a quick question. Planning to travel soon and I have an I-797 that I travelled with back in June. Upon re-entry, they took a look and stamped my passport valid until June 11, 2028 which matches both the I-797 and my latest I94.

What doesn't match is the I94 number on my I-797 which is different from my latest I94 (issued after recent cross).

When I cross, I typically present both my passport and printed I94. Should I continue this to provide all documents up front? Or do folks who travel with an I-797 also present this as well?

Note: I will not be travelling from a preclearance site but will be travelling to EWR.