GARP hate is undeserved

I don't understand why people are like garps much weaker than white beard because he only took one ice attack to the chest while whitebeard took all the other damage by mean first of all there's a 10 years age Gap aging 10 years up from White Beard's age is already a major loss in power cuz 76 and I'm pretty sure whitebeard was 66 that's still a big age Gap and white beards a buccaneer a race that is a lot more sturdy and GARP didn't die he was just trying to get the others out of the island safely so I still think garp stronger