valentines day/bday/anniversary wknd recs

my boyfriend and i (both 21+) are visiting nyc from chicago mid february for a whole bunch of celebrations that all fall around the same time and im hoping you guys can help us out with some planning. i have been before to do most of the touristy things but it’s his first time. we already have tickets to tour the statue of liberty and we’re seeing a show on broadway on valentines day, other than that we are open to anything. we love anything artsy, would love some cool thrift/vintage store places to check out, best bagel and coffee spots, cool nightlife for people who don’t really actually like going out that much or drinking lmao??