Just finished my first play-through… incredible. Help me decide what to do next?

I just finished the game for the first time and totally loved it. Truly a masterpiece of a game and I’m so glad I picked it up.

My first time through I was as honorable as I could be and helped John in the end.

So now I have to decide what to do next. I only made it to like 88% total completion, so I could stay in the post epilogue with John and try to get 100% completion. Option 2, I could start a new low honor play through. Option 3, I could go play RDR1, which I have not played yet.

Honestly, after completing a high honor run, I can’t imagine Arthur as a bad person, and part of me doesn’t want to play with him that way, although I imagine it’s fun and profitable to kill indiscriminately lol.

Thoughts?