r/Scams•
buffychrome

[US] Very weird or very good job recruiting scam or maybe legit

Is this a scam?

Wife received an email over the weekend from someone claiming to be an independent recruiter head-hunting for a senior role at a company she and I both worked at for years. We’ve had an email conversation for three days. If it’s a scam, I’m struggling to understand its purpose.

Red flags:

  • Sent from a personal Gmail address
  • Found a corresponding LinkedIn account (not verified) with no posts.
  • Google and reverse image searches don’t confirm their identity but don’t reveal anything negative.
  • Never claims to be able to have a direct phone call.

Green or beige flags:

  • The posting in the emails looks and sounds legitimate, though it’s for a job not currently posted.
  • The posting is for a senior, director-level position within my wife’s knowledge and experience.
  • The posting uses unique verbiage and formatting typical of the company.
  • The initial email was sent directly to my wife’s personal email, not via a job site.
  • The “recruiter” hasn’t asked for personal information, pressured her to move to WhatsApp or other chat apps, asked for money, or done anything I’d consider a scam target.
  • The emails are well-written, professional, and natural-sounding, with responses to various questions.
  • The initial email was detailed and looked like a real recruiter’s email.
  • The only request she’s made is for her resume, and now a cover letter and executive summary brief
  • there has been no pressure or requests for anything more than these

Here’s the thing: if this was a scam, what’s the goal here? Everything so far is proceeding like a normal recruitment process. Yet, part of me still feels like it is and I just haven’t figured out what their goal is yet.

Any thoughts on this?

Posted Dec 1, 2025, 8:23 PM UTC

139
Loading comments…