r/mlb•
DonT012

Position Players vs Pitchers. Who would win?

:Message: | Discussion

Let's suppose you have a matchup between a team of all position players and a team of all pitchers. Who would win in a 7 game series.

Rules:

  • No two way players allowed.
  • Must be around league-average ERA+ pitchers vs average OPS+ hitters.
  • Can use up to 26 players on each team.
  • Neither team gets a DH.

Posted Dec 5, 2025, 3:21 PM UTC

3768
Loading comments…