DAE seem to have a knack for "sensing" bad people before NT people do?

It's a cycle for me:

-I meet someone new.

-Something immediately seems off about them....like my brain is telling me to run away

-I'll brush it off as paranoia/judgement because the people around me say they're nice

-Every. Single. Time. I turn out to be correct about my initial thought.

But I never do or say anything about it, because I don't want to come off as some judgemental butthead. Then it turns out: I was right! This person sucks! Then I feel bad for thinking that. I have a few examples:

-A professor who I met, I felt unsafe in his class albiet he had 5 stars on RateMyProfessor and everyone around me LOVED him. I dropped out a week in. 2 months later? Arrested for committing.....inhumane crimes, to put it lightly.

-A coworker I immediately felt off about....gave him the benefit of the doubt since he was so friendly. He wound up getting fired for harassing staff & clients.

-A boss I also felt unsafe with when I met her. Brushed it off as new job jitters. Wound up being super ableist & would pick on disabled staff.

-A friend of my partner who I felt weird abt when I met him. Also brushed off to make my partner happy. Wound up destroying the friend group by causing drama.

Please tell me I'm not the only one.