I have this dating problem...
OK, here's the deal. I live in a major metro area of the United States. I was in a relationship for nearly 9 years up until maybe a year and a half ago, so I've been out of the game, but trying to get back in. I'm on Scruff, yes looking for love ultimately but certainly open to hookups.
If I take a step back, I feel like I'm pretty high quality. I'm 42, tall, successful, very fit, have well-written profile text that describes interests, etc. And when I do meet guys, they seem to think I'm super hot and good company.
The problem I'm having is that, while guys seem to really like me in person, I'm having the hardest time getting to an in-person meet. Guys seem content to chat for a bit, then disappear. It's not like I'm suggesting that we go to the opera, just grabbing a drink or something. If I do end up getting to the point of trying to arrange a meet, people seem to be flaky and noncommittal ("maybe this weekend", "let's play it by ear", "been a busy week") and after a few of those messages I start to feel like I'm chasing, which is definitely unsexy. I'm a busy guy, but if I'm genuinely interested in someone, I'm going to stay engaged and make time to meet up.
I know some people will say Scruff is not a good place to actually meet people. I would respond that it seems to be where most of the people are, so as a numbers game it's not a bad play. Or that I need to go out and meet people in person, etc. But my friends tend to be straight or married gays that are not really into going out anymore. Sports leagues seem to be suggested, and I see the merit, but trying to fit that into the schedule is daunting. So I'm trying to figure out how to steer conversations towards an in-person meeting without it seeming premature or desperate. Feel like I must be doing something wrong.
Any advice? Starting to feel very demoralized.
Posted Dec 6, 2025, 10:34 PM UTC