Rimming sensitivity question

Is it weird to not feel any pleasure from getting your ass licked? Usually when I rim guys they go feral. They moan, pant and beg me not to stop. I've even made guys cum from just tongue-fucking them why stroking their cocks.

I recently hooked up with this guy who didn't react in any way when I first kissed his hole. He was silent for a few minutes and then told me that getting rimmed does nothing for him and that I should just pound his ass already. So I fucked him good and hard. Afterwards on my way home I felt unsatisfied in a way because I get pleasure from rimming guys and seeing them squirm in extacy. I've never hooked up with a guy who didn't love my ass eating skills and it's making feel weird. Are there a lot of guys like this or is this just a one off experience?