rebel•

http://www.christiandomesticdiscipline.com/Freechapter3.html

That's a free chapter from one of the books.

Talk about subverting christianity! Geezus, it's spank porn!

41
wjv•

My first thought was, "Please let this be some elaborate satire, since I don't think there's room left for my opinion of these people to sink any lower."

Then I skimmed that "free chapter" and... yah, you're right. "CDD" is just an excuse for them to consume a little spank pr0n guilt-free.

(Gads, the writing makes alt.sex.stories look like literature.)

25
Whisper•

I think that it's also a guilt-free excuse for hardline christians to be BDSM lifestylers without admitting it even to themselves.

22
Phia•

Which is downright sad. I remember reading an article by a dominant woman explaining how her husband being a sub didn't make them bad Christians because she still deferred to her husband otherwise.

11
clarion•

This is nothing but domestic abuse. There are laws against this, but these women probably don't realize that.

15
Tiarlynn•

I don't consider this domestic abuse, frankly. The website even says that the woman must consent. What this is is a really weird excuse to mask a fairly run-of-the-mill Dom/sub relationship under the guise of "good Christian values," because god forbid people have untoward sexual desires.

10
berberine•

I'm sorry but I do consider it domestic abuse. The guy comes home, smacks the shit out of his wife for disobeying him, beats her and then has sex with her and says, "this is what I really came home for."

If you want to say CDD = sub/dom relationships, that's fine as they're trying to pretty up what many christians think of as something dirty.

This story/chapter, however, describes domestic abuse though, not a little bit of kinky sex.

14
Tiarlynn•

You're right, this story does take the idea too far. What I imagine (and very much hope), this is essentially sensationalized erotic fiction, which is what it reads like. Also, it's not my scene, so feel free to correct me, but a lot of D/s practices aren't necessarily explicitly sexual in nature, and more based on discipline or humiliation.

Given the nature of this sort of fiction, then, I'd normally consider this story par for the course even given the wife's fairly disturbing dubious consent; the fact that it's told within the bounds of a website instructing similar behaviors is the only thing that gives me pause. Perhaps it's naive of me, but I do hope that people reading it can treat it as a sort of exaggerated and eroticised fiction instead of an instruction manual.

However, within the context of a consensual relationship, nothing this fiction describes bothers me. The fact that the wife doesn't seem fully consensual is what makes this seem abusive and disturbing.

10
mingthepanda•

Good point - this way, there's no need for a trip to the confessional after every 'dirty' episode... Ugh.

6
Phia•

But what will celibate priests have to amuse them, then?

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
mingthepanda•

I think that's the point - there is no real reason to tie it to religion at all, it's only so they don't feel guilty over their 'impure' acts. If there wasn't a way to tie it to religion, these people (being discussed) potentially wouldn't explore or enjoy that side of their sexuality at all.

At least, I know that was my problem with it. ;)

1
mingthepanda•

From the chapter: "Though she didn’t feel like reaching her own climax, his lovemaking comforted Alyssa, and by the time he was through she had stopped crying and her heart felt much better. "

Exactly. When I don't 'reach climax' during sex, it's just because I didn't feel like it. I'm not saying I always need to orgasm to enjoy sex with a man, but that just sounds like a softer form of rape IMO.

9
yasth•

Eh there are times when a guy or girl doesn't want an orgasm. Of course they often involve yeast infections. In this case yeah, male ego boosting.

Anyways. From the forums I would guess there are a fair number of females who are attracted to this. You really must read the forums they are resplendent in their ... specialness

2
mingthepanda•

We're in total agreement about not always wanting an orgasm - sometimes it's just too much work!

LOL, and I'm afraid that if I read the forums I'd do something awfully self-destructive. ;) More 'specialness' than I can handle.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
[deleted]•

So it is spank porn for Christians! Well then, what are we arguing about? Let's get to the reading!

7
Whisper•

Hey, don't be bigoted. Let the christians have their S&M, too.

21
lynnmag•
21
wjv•

If you think they look weird, wait till you hear the reason for them. A blog post on that site reads, in part:

THEN my husband threw a wrench in my spokes when he asked me to stop wearing underwear under my skirts. This was NOT an order, so don’t go getting all upset with him. This was him half-jokingly telling me he’d really love it if I were perpetually “available” to him, and since he is such a wonderful husband, I wanted to submit to that request.

So now on cold days I wear crotch-less pantaloons with knee-high socks or hose. They are made from soft cotton muslin. They usually have a ruffle or lace at the edge. They are comfortable and definitely make me feel feminine, and I am still “available” for my husband. Problem solved.

I'm not sure where the Bible ends and the Story of O begins, frankly.

4
sisternovena•

Gah! I was just about to post that link.

I'm shocked at myself for thinking this, but that's actually kind of brilliant in its irony. I think... I think I want some!

2
[deleted]•

Yeah, it's a BDSM website in disguise.

20
metmerc•

If only the rest of the people making comments could get that.

3
buildmonkey•

Is it just me that read that as 'pre-washed muslim'?

2
[deleted]•

If only wardrobe had given Linda Blair a pair of these, the Exorcist's underwear budget wouldn't have blown out.

1
[deleted]•

You mean it was washed away. It's not exactly water under the bridge, but that ship has sailed.

1
[deleted]•

Are we talking about the same movie?

2
[deleted]•

wee wee are.

1
nicolaslloyd•

you just made me lol in my pants.

1
[deleted]•

Jesus and I love you very much. Now don't make me tell you again.

20
wageslave•

Q) What do you correct a women with two black eyes? A) Dont bother, She didnt listen to first two times.

I_AM_KIDDING Real physical assault is not funny. Jokes are funny. Laugh.

-8
[deleted]•

An extremely old joke + an explanation that it is a joke... less funny.

16
DTanner•

Ah, so that's where the problem is, they can't tell the difference between a child and a woman. That must be why they're always fucking children and beating their wives!

19
ellsmall•

"Loving wife spanking in a Christian Marriage" LoLz!

13
[deleted]•

[removed]

11
hopeseekr•

That's how mine is ;) well, she expects me to spank her when she's bad, too; and she's naughty on purpose all the time >_<

13
davodrums•

Get a room you two.

9
jodes•

Yeah, with a big window and no curtains.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Whisper•

A SAM. SAMs can be fun, but they can also be annoying.

1
cartooncorpse•

at last something christians and i can agree on!

12
Phia•

What, S&M hidden under the guise of domestic bliss? I thought as a Libertarian athiest you'd be capable of doing it without an excuse.

1
cartooncorpse•

i wouldn't, as a Libertarian, victimize anyone. my 'discipline' would be quid pro quo based. if 'you' bashed me in the head with a skillet, prepare to have your lights punched out. Libertarians are tough on victimizers. chicks need to learn not to go there (physical assault) without having the 'tail' to CASH that check.

-1
Phia•

What's that got to do with S&M? I don't believe in hitting people except in pervy or protective contexts. Did you read the website or did you just latch onto the idea of hitting women and run with it?

I don't think 'you' would punch me out if I clubbed 'you' with a skillet. I use cast iron cookware, so 'you' would more likely wake up in the emergency ward and then press charges, unless I was justified in hitting 'you', at which point a concussion would be the -least- of 'your' worries.

0
cartooncorpse•

no i just latched onto the idea that the christians finally said something i could agree with.

yeah well charges or punches whichever seems appropriate. my point being that the scenario "chick hits dude, dude hits back, dude goes to jail" is NOT justice. and i've had the displeasure to be around a number of chicks who think they get to assault guys, but are victimized if the guy returns the favor.

no i really wasn't reading the site for its intended purpose i suppose. just read the first few lines.

-1
vervejunkie•

"It's worth mentioning that a wife is supposed to submit to her man, rather than fight"

It doesn't mention that a husband is supposed to be a real man and not get emotionally freaked out enough to hit a woman.

wwjd and all that crap... This manual is giving every dumb sheep instructions on how to be even dumber.

10
fbg111•

Pretty sad that your comment is the best yet on this article, yet two people modded you down. You're absolutely right that real men don't resort to physical violence to quash the woman they supposedly love, there's nothing weaker or more pathetic. Real men master their temper and work through relationship problems with their significant other, and save the violence for the battlefield or back alley mugger. As Asimov said, violence is the last refuge of the incompetent. This manual is just giving justification to stupid men to remain so.

6
[deleted]•

"As Asimov said, violence is the last refuge of the incompetent."

Is that why women can slap men with impunity?

0
fbg111•

That's not a good thing either, however it's not exactly equivalent. If a woman has slapped you, 1) you probably did something to deserve it, as women just don't go around randomly slapping men, and 2) most women aren't strong enough to physically hurt a man with a slap anyway, unless she accidentally puts a finger in his eye or something. At worst, it's the guy's ego that gets bruised, which isn't necessarily a bad thing.

But having said that, Asimov's quote still stands. If woman slaps a guy, it's b/c the situation has reached a point where she's no longer able to use wit or cleverness to difuse or handle, and loses her temper. The result is less damaging than vice versa, but still not a good thing.

0
[deleted]•
  1. you probably did something to deserve it, as women just don't go around randomly slapping men,

So men can, by nonviolence, deserve to have violence inflicted upon them, but cannot respond violently even when a woman is violent toward them. Thank you for putting me in my place.

  1. Most women aren't strong enough to physically hurt a man with a slap anyway, unless she accidentally puts a finger in his eye or something.

Many women are, and most girls are until the onset of puberty, whether they know it or not. Only "momma's boys" are allowed to cry. Girls get hugs for doing it. Boys are punished for hitting girls, even if girls hit them first, twice.

Maybe you haven't seen a girl - girl fight; I have, and I've been shocked at the cruelty that they can inflict on each other. Not all girls are made of sugar and cinnamon.

It all boils down to the demonic canard that women are incapable of hurting men, therefore they are allowed every attempt to do so, while men are commonly aggressors, therefore must be exclusively bound by laws to limit their aggression.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

9
greenknight•

Let me guess... Jesus' Evaluation of Husbands Handiwork??

5
mckirkus•

Jesus' pimp hand is strong.

3
double0seven•

How about "Wife Filing for Divorce"? Oh wait, she's not allowed.

1
chucker•

From Amazon.com's book page:

Maintenance...Again

9:04 AM PST, December 16, 2006

My husband informed me this morning we were going to have a maintenance session this evening for the first time in months.

As I mentioned in a previous blog, I've been having a hard time keeping things in order. My husband thinks a maintenance session might help me get back on track. I have neglected my health as of late and have been a bit ill, followed by an exacerbation of fibromyalgia. I am behind on housework a bit (just a bit--I've been careful to keep that going). I'm behind on homeschooling. My husband calls these the three H's-- Health, House, Homeschooling. Letting these slide will get me in trouble faster than anything.

Thankfully, my husband tells me we are not starting regular maintenance again, just doing one session to keep things from escalating until I earn a punishment spanking. I have to agree, though I'm not looking forward to it. Maintenance is quite uncomfortable. I hope this one session will help.

Hope everyone is having a wonderful Christmas season!

Blessings,

Leah

That's the book's author. I can't tell whether this is some elaborate form of satire (with Leah laughing her head off over the morons who actually buy her "literature"), or whether Leah is just completely insane. "The three Hs"? I've heard that before, except in historical context of almost two centuries ago, back when women had no rights.

9
jotaroh•

LMAO @ the three Hs

3
double0seven•

Because having your house clean for your husband is so much more important than your kids getting a decent education...

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
TheManWithNoName•

So is this what they mean by traditional family values?

7
[deleted]•

Just as our culture is turned upside down in so many other things, the traditional Christian marriage is no exception.

The "traditional Christian marriage" can kindly fuck off and die.

7
kungfooey•

What the heck? I thought this was sarcasm, too, but apparently it's not. There's waaayyy too much information here, so it's either a very concentrated effort at satire or it's serious. Either way, a Google shows that the only sites that link to this are spank-porn websites, and apparently there is a foru, and a guestbook with many entries.

5
dabhaid•

It's intriguing to ponder exactly to whom a husband might apply for consent to discipline his wife...

4
Snoron•

I was wondering this myself. Surely if someone is in "need" of discipline, they'd be the last person to ask for it... otherwise why would you be acting in a way which needs disciplinary action.. hmm! The mysteries of Christianity..

3
derefr•

Haven't you ever heard the phrase "I've been a very, very naughty girl. Whatever are you going to do to me?" before?

3
jimmywanger•

I think most people don't understand.

You only discipline her when she JUST DOESN'T LISTEN.

4
ivananic•

And while we are at it, let's bring back slavery and crusades... Oh wait..

3
[deleted]•

“SPLAT! SMACK! SPLAT! SPLAT! SPLAT!” The blows sounded even louder because of her wet suit.

WFT! That's porn!

3
yasth•

Quotes from the forums: On whether or not crying is necessary

I haven't cried yet. I hope to since I've heard so many express what a great relief it is. But I know when the spanking is working. Something in me clicks and I start to feel relaxed and have a great deisre to submit to my man. I really need the 'click' though. Sometimes my husband wants to quit-he's tired and I understand that. But if he quits too soon I feel completely off balanced and usually worse. So men-don't give up!

A 45 year old man looking for a love

I want a woman that desires to become the property of her husband. A woman that longs to be completely submissive and controlled by a strict yet loving man that will be her owner, pastor and father as well as husband. she will have no rights except those which I grant her. she will dress as I tell her; I will always know where she is and who she is with. her body will belong to Me and I will take it when I choose, how I choose. If called for, she will be disciplined by Me in a physical manner. That said, I would never keep her away from family or friends. I would never keep her prisoner in the home.

An 18 year woman tries to come to terms:

I had felt the need for correction and discipline for all my life and only when I had come of age did I discover lifestyles- non-Christian lifestyles, mind you- that would meet such a need. I fell into an online society that held Daddy/little girl roles in their relationships, and I found myself with a man whom I’d never met and consented to call him my “Daddy” and had to ask permission for every single thing I did when I was “with” him. I ended the relationship before it went too far, and repented for abandoning my Christian lifestyle for something not of God.

Truthfully I think it is a good thing. I mean better this then leading a life even more sexually repressed

3
bali-song•

That last comment reminded me of the "Purity Balls" that some of these people throw. Purity Balls are dances where fathers take their daughters to dance the night away in a Christian setting and the climax of the night invloves the fathers slipping their daughters rings. These rings are supposed to symbolize the daughters' "purity." Basically it's daddy telling his little girl that he owns her vagina until he gives to someone else.

4
bobcat•

Jewish girls need spanking, too!

3