What charlie87 believers love to ignore about the novels (also movie spoilers)

SpoilerDebunk

Basically since fnaf 2 movie released, charlie87 believers has been using it to say that charlie83 “lost” evidence because since charlie died in 1982 in the movies and in the novels she dies in 1983, it shows that charlie dying in a different year then the novels is possible since theres this difference between continuities and in a way yes, they are correct about this statement, theres the difference that makes this argument extremely flawed and that charlie87 believers love to ignore… charlie’s death in the novels was retconned to 1983, because in the silver eyes its said that “sammy” (actually being charlie) died in october 1982 in fredbears, also being said that they were 3 years when this happened, making sammy and charlie being born in 1979, which in itself is also a contradiction since charlie is said to be 7 years old in 1985 and 17 in 1995, which would make her and sammy being born in 1978, not 1979. With that in mind, the fourth closet deliberately retcons charlie’s death to 1983 and also her birthday, now in 1980 instead of 1978/79, which implies now she dies in october 1983 and debunks the “she was kidnapped by william in october 1982 but only considered dead in 1983” because her birthday was also changed (which was already inconsistency). And this retcon was deliberately made in the fourth closet, that was being written probably at the same time as fnaf 6 and in fnaf 6 we see charlie’s death in the security puppet minigame and released at the same time as UCN and when fnaf 6 lore discussion were still happening, so with that in mind, Althoght yes, charlie’s death is different in the movies, you can still use TFC as evidence for charlie83 because it was a change that scott deliberately choose to make in the book series

Posted Dec 7, 2025, 11:47 PM UTC

3437
Loading comments…