Trade-in exceeds cars value, tax question.

Canadian Sale

So I'm trading in a car and looking for equity back. This one dealer's quote for my trade-in is low compared to others. They say well the other dealers quotes are higher because those are not including the tax saved? this feels off to me.

e.g. the tax on the car I would buy is 5k. Dealer 1 offered 50k for my trade. Dealer 2 is only offering 45k but claims anyone offering 50k is just counting that 5k tax saved in their trade (to make it 50k). Dealer says this is standard practice but they don't do it to be transparent.

I am waiting to hear back from dealer 1 but I want to know is this really a standard thing?

Posted Dec 8, 2025, 9:50 PM UTC

111

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 11 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.