Convert from 401K or Regular IRA? Tax Implications?
I am thinking about converting some money into Roth to fill up my 12% bracket (retired now but pre-SS and living on after-tax savings).
I realized over the years, for my non-deductible IRA contributions, I did not consistently do that IRS form (8606?) to establish my basis. I can't get this done before year end. I know I have to eventually do this.
So, I am thinking maybe I can convert from my pre-tax 401K. Does it make a difference math-wise either way? For the same taxable dollar amount, I suppose I can convert more if I go from the non-deductible IRA once the basis is subtracted?
My 401K also has some after-tax money. I read that if you convert the after-tax money, you have to drag some pre-tax money with it based on the proportion, creating more taxable income. It seems the reverse might or might not be true (i.e. can move pre-tax money without dragging after-tax money), depending on the 401K plan?
Also, I have been making estimated tax payments every quarter without taking this into consideration. If I convert in December and just pay the additional expected income tax in the January 15 2025 Estimated Tax payment, would the IRS have an issue with it?
Thanks.
Posted Dec 11, 2025, 9:52 AM UTC