cracking each other's eggs (sorta)
a love story
Married, been together ~13 years, straight couple, not young (we were each born toward the end of the 1970s)
My wife is a rock-solid civil rights person, like way deep in the trenches, works with the political action arm of reproductive rights groups and testifies in front of the state congress in her spare time while keeping up her job in a traditionally all-male blue-collar career environment, inspires the family to go volunteer on a reservation instead of eating turkey every thanksgiving, teaches other white women about intersectionality, just a badass.
But every so often she gets weeeeeeird talking about trans people. It puts my hackles way the fuck up and starts some near-arguments; I have always had nonbinary and trans friends and family. The love of my life veering even a *little* close to the TERF zone just sets of all my alarm bells. Worse, seeing me get visibly upset about it makes her wonder out loud why I'm so into trans people, anyway?? Just not a cool vibe. It's like she is extra jumpy because of all the times people have made assumptions about her as a woman who is outspoken and take-charge in social situations and who works in male-dominated spaces and lifts heavy at the gym with no regard to how 'feminine' she looks. She is just a woman who doesn't feel bound by other people's ideas of how women should be, that's all.
At the same time, the joke of the household is what a totally standard-issue straight guy I am; I talk like the encyclopedia of woke queerness but I am straight as a ruler and vanilla as an ice cream cone. It's a funny dichotomy. I am used to this joke and I get it; I was always the token straight boy in the theatre and modern dance spaces where I spent my teens and early 20s.
I learned how to be firm but gentle in turning down come-ons from male friends and colleagues who thought I was cute or mistook my emotionally open friendship for something else, and after a while it didn't even make me feel confused and panicked. Hell, it would have been simpler if I *was* attracted to dudes, but alas I was only ever into lady parts. I had never even seen another man's penis up close, except for that one unasked for penis when I was a little kid, but I dealt with that according to the healthy standard of my generation by Never Mentioning It until I was like 30, and then talking about it as if it was no big deal because some people have real problems, you know? And I'm a privileged straight white dude, let's don't forget. I'm at peace with that, I'm just not attracted to dudes. Totally straight.
You already know where this is going and you are correct
Anyway: fast-forward years, for various reasons we allllll go to therapy. Couples therapy, individual therapy for both as well, it's lucky I have a well-paying Straight White Guy job with good insurance.
The wife declares she thinks she is maybe nonbinary, and would it be ok if I try using they/them pronouns with her? I mean them? And of course it's ok and I will do that. Later it becomes more clear to them that nonbinary means they could still take T and get a lower voice, they've always felt like their voice was too high and sounded like someone who isn't them. That's not gonna be a problem right? I mean, to me - their husband - they carefully express that they believe I love them because they are them and not for how exactly they sound or if they dress feminine, right? Or if they have perhaps a little bottom growth as a result of the T, that's not even a big deal right?
And no, it isn't. I confidently tell them that I am now and have always been in love with them, and even if I was to be shallow, I've always been attracted to sorta-masculine women so what's really different about this, anyway? They should stop worrying about me and make the choices that let them be more completely their real self.
Am I worried about me? I mean, a little bit. My partner (not wife!) has said a bunch of times, they are not trying to identify as a 'man' and that they don't want to like grow a beard or pass or something, they are just trying more masculine presentation and hormones and all that because their sense of nonbinary identity is taking them there. But if they did want to present even more masculine, that would be ok right?
What's the limit? There's a point where I can no longer hang?
I don't think so. I confidently state that they have already told me they don't think of themselves as a man and I know I'm not hung up about specific body shapes or anything else like that, I just love my partner. I mean, I'm straight so there's some limit somewhere I guess, I just don't know where exactly. But it shouldn't be a problem.
Interesting thing about the T is that it causes some part of my partner to click into the fact that they are attracted to women. That has never been the case before.... that they could admit to themself, anyway; maybe they were hung up because they hated people making assumptions about them as a woman in male-dominated career spaces and hobbies. But it's too obvious to ignore now. Bisexual it seems!
Cool from my perspective; I wouldn't have predicted "open relationship so my nonbinary partner can figure out a whole unexplored half of their sexuality" as one of the possible futures we'd end up in together but I'm surprisingly ok with it. It's fun listening to my partner gush about dates with women, and how fascinating their bodies are (I agree wholeheartedly!)
I have permission to be doing the same thing of course, I just am not prioritizing that right this second, my work is busy and anyway I'm not finding out something new if I find a woman to hook up with. I already know I like that lol
Would I ever touch a dick, my partner asks me? I mean: if you wanted to watch me do that because it'd be hot for you to watch, then I would go for it; I'm pretty game for most anything. Would I seek that out though? Naw, I'm straight.
Fast forward another few months - my partner is now post-top surgery, still on T but no longer taking the other one (that slows body hair and bottom growth), and is on a track toward 'passing' for male even if they keep identifying as transmasc non-binary. Oh, and they are exclusively attracted to women.
Regretfully, we are breaking up.
We don't hate each other's guts or anything, and I got to come along on a very weird and confusing-to-me-journey of finding myself more attracted to my partner as they got more masculine-presenting. Also because of the whole open relationship thing, even though I really wasn't actively looking, I must be putting out "I'm single" energy because I keep getting hit on in public. By both women and men, hilariously! Also, isn't it weird that one of those circumstances makes me feel warmly complementary, while the other one makes me feel butterflies and heart-pounding and kind of buzzy behind the eyes and grinning about something or other I don't understand myself? What's that about, anyway?
...
... ... ... ...
Oh geez. Wait, really?
,,,
I could write more paragraphs but in practice what's going down right now is me counting down the next couple of weeks until my lease starts on my new place, and my partner is going on dates with cute girls while I go on dates with cute boys. My almost-50-year-old former 'wife' is complaining about how chicks don't put any effort into messaging back on dating apps and the cost of buying coffee or cocktails while she gets to know some woman, and I'm learning how to talk to people differently on like Hinge or Tinder than on Grindr. And.... I dunno what next, story isn't done yet.
Cheers and hope that was entertaining to some of y'all :)
Posted Dec 14, 2025, 6:21 AM UTC