The Two Wives: The First Night Continues

NSFWFiction

John David couldn't recall being more ready for anything in his life. He loved marrying Sara, wanting sex with her, but nothing could've compared to having sex with both of his wives in this moment. All he could do was nod quickly in response. Both women giggled and Sara brought him closer for a kiss.

Sara was an excellent kisser, very fluid with her lips, turning him on more and more with each flick of her tongue. Emilee kept kissing around his body, moving her hands around that still told him she was appreciative of him being her husband and what he gave her. It was very different from Sara and the way they interacted, but he still loved it all the same and enjoyed any attention she gave him.

In a quick movement, Sara moved her body around him and forced him down onto the bed. "I can't do it anymore my love, I need you inside me desperately!" She didn't have to tell him twice and positioned her body so she could sink herself down onto his cock. He laid back to give her room and held his breath as he watched his first wife make his cock disappear inside her.

Her hips started to move back and forth, hands in her hair, starting slow to get used to him. He forced his hips into her and she cried out in both pleasure and pain. Sara always bottomed out on top and he knew it, he enjoyed toying with her when she thought she was in charge. Sara however liked to dish it out too and gave him a mischievous grin.

Pleasure coursed through him as she rode him recklessly, back and forth like she was on an actual horse galloping away. As if that weren't bad enough, she brought Emilee towards her and started to kiss her. That did him in. As much as he didn't want to spill his seed yet, the view of both women kissing above him while Sara rode him like a mad woman made him explode!

John David saw stars as he lay back and felt the waves crash into him over and over again. He could still hear the women kissing above him, but his eyes were too heavy to open. His whole body was too heavy to move currently. However, he did feel Sara get off of him and lay next to him. What must have been Emilee's body brushed against his arm as she lay next to him. He didn't know what was going on, but he heard Sara start moaning again next to him.

Confused, he lifted his head, but what he saw he would never be prepared for! Sara was laying down with her head at his feet and her legs spread apart. Emilee had her head between Sara's legs again, but this time she was lapping up John David's seed out of Sara as it dropped out!

John David didn't know how these women did it, every time he thought he couldn't get more turned on, they surpassed the last time he couldn't take any more. As much as he was enjoying himself, there was just a little fear to what these women were capable of and the unknown to where it would lead him.

John David awoke between the two women in the middle of the night. He tried to remember what had been happening, what had transpired the last couple of weeks, but there was way too much to list at this point.

He felt Sara stir next to him and he tried to make out her face in the darkness. Even when they first met, he knew he wanted to marry this woman. She was so fierce even if she hid most of it on the inside. It was like a moth to a flame that only he could see. Her blonde hair and forest green eyes were the perfect match for him to do nothing but fall hard for her.

Emilee also moved at his other side. He swiveled his head towards her and tried to look at her like he did Sara. Emilee was far from ordinary, she was very stunning! Most of the men couldn't understand why she wasn't interested in courtship, but knowing what he did now, it made sense. Her dark hair shone in the sunlight beautifully and provided an excellent contrast to her blue grey eyes. She was like a storm on the sea, if you didn't watch out, she would show you what she's made of. Her joy for life was unmatched, she blew him away with all the differences she saw in the world. Even though she didn't love him the same as Sara, he cared for her and loved her in a way only a husband could.

A hand brushed the side of his face and pulled him back towards Sara. She kissed him lightly and moaned into his mouth as her hand slid down the side of it. "I'd really love to make love to my husband if he doesn't mind."

She captured his mouth again and he moaned into her. He would never mind pleasing his own wife. He rolled over on top of her and pressed her into the bedding. Her legs went around his waist and arms around his neck hugging him to her. Moans echoed throughout the room and he felt a hand lightly brush against his arm. Considering Sara's were both around his neck, it could only be Emilee reaching for him.

He carassed her hand between his cheek and shoulder, wanting her to feel the same affection he was showing Sara even if it was in a different way. Emilee kissed his temple, then went back to touching his arm and left side, letting him know she was there.

Sara had been ready when she awoke, but feeling Emilee's hand and John David's movements to make her feel loved turned her on even more. As confusing as it was especially in her sleepy state, it made her happy that he loved Emilee so much. She didn't feel as if his love for her was going towards Emilee like she did before. This time it felt like his love was expanding! She thought about her love for her kids. One wasn't more loved than the other and yes it was different from one to the other, but it didn't deminish the love she had, it only expanded.

Her hands traveled down his body until it reached his cock. She slowly hand over hand pulled it towards her, over and over again until he came towards her. John David rubbed himself up and down Sara's slit until he felt he was lubricated enough to slide in. The familiar "pop" was felt by both of them as he began his entrance inside her.

Emilee couldn't see much, but she played the role of supporting wife well. She knew John David and Sara needed this moment together and as much as she loved the both of them, they had a different kind of love that she couldn't be apart of. There was a little bit of jealousy in the beginning when she knew she could never have that with a man, but as time went by she felt comfortable with her role. She would be the supportive wife, the lover of her friend, and that was more than enough for her.

John David lowered his forehead onto Sara's as he heard her moans start to turn to whimpers. His hips ground into her over and over, moving like a wave to give Sara more than enough stimulation with the different angles. He felt the fingernails dig into his back from Sara and the contrast of Emilee's fingers lightly trailing down his arm. The stimulation was heady and drove him mad. He loved these women, both equally but differently in a way he would never fully grasp in this life.

Sara came loudly and arched her back off the bed causing John David to explode and pull her tight into him. Breathing was all that could be heard in the stillness of the quiet room. Emilee moved her hand down to John David's forearm and rubbed circles around it. He let go of Sara for a moment and reached for Emilee's head to bring her in for a quick kiss. Sara put her hands on the back of his neck and brought his forehead back to hers.

"I love you so much John David. You are the best thing that could've happend to me."

John David kissed Sara fiercely, "You'll always be mine. I love you to much in this life it scares me how much I will in the next."

Sara gave a small giggle, then started to reach for Emilee. "Emilee I....I love you too. We were supposed to be friends, but now I see why God did what He did. He knew my heart and how I felt about you. I can never make up for the past, but my life isn't complete without you in it anymore."

John David rolled off Sara so the women could have their moment and laid on his side. He felt Emilee's leg wrap hit his own as it wrapped around Sara and pulled her close. "I love you too Sara. You were the most beautiful girl I had ever seen that first day at the creek. As much as I wanted to have you, I would've never expected this. I love this family and I'm so grateful for both of you."

John David felt Emilee's hand reach past Sara and touch his side. He brought it up to his lips and kissed her palm gently, then laid it on Sara's side. They would be ok. No matter what happened in the future, he knew God would make it ok.

Posted Jan 8, 2026, 2:46 AM UTC

60
Loading comments…