The Two Wives: Conclusion #1

NSFWFiction

John David looked around the cabin he had once built for Emilee. A few weeks had passed and winter had landed in the valley, just in time for him to put the finishing touches on the cabin. There was only one problem, Emilee didn't want it anymore. In fact, none of them wanted her to live in it. Emilee had moved into their cabin and shared their bed with her. People talked in the settlement about it, but once John David reported to the brethren that he preferred his family together and he was ready to expand his cabin instead, the whispers slowly died down.

That only left one problem: what to do with the cabin he just put his blood, sweat, and a few tears from a hammer to the thumb into?? Thankfully another young couple had moved into the valley and loved the location! They bought it from John David for a fair price and he had used the money for a down payment on the new cabin expansion.

When winter came, it was too cold to do any work outside unless necessary. He would start in the spring and slowly build a half cabin in the back of the original one. One room would be "Emilee's", but that was purely for show, and the other would be the newest addition to their family. Even though Emilee still wasn't very interested in sex with his cock involved, she still allowed him to empty his seed inside her so she could have the children she wanted. The children they all wanted.

John David and Sara were just as excited for the baby as Emilee was. Even though the baby wasn't hers, you would think Sara was the one that was pregnant! She was constantly fawning over Emilee and making sure she was comfortable. If she wasn't doing that, she was making baby clothes or teaching the children some toy or gift they could make for the baby. John David absolutely loved Sara, but he knew she loved Emilee just the same.

The women had sex just as much as he did with Sara. Sometimes he would come home with the kids gone and the two of them were rubbing their pussies together or humping each others legs. Multiple times he had caught fingers in places they shouldn't have been or heads hidden beneath skirts. He only shook his head and smiled, sometimes joining in and other times leaving them to their fun. With Emilee's pregnancy getting further along, they definitely were getting in all the free time they could with each other.

One morning he came home to the exact scene he had been thinking of before entering through the door. Emilee was laying on the bed naked, legs spread with Sara on top of her grinding away. Sara looked to him and said "Oh John you're home! Good, I had the best idea and need your help. Get naked please."

Well how could he refuse that? He smiled as he stripped down, watching the show in front of him and wondering what his wives had in store for him. As he climbed onto the bed, Sara climbed off Emilee and hovered over her. She put her hand on Emilee's cheek and asked, "Do you trust me sweetheart?"

Emilee smiled, "With all that I am."

Sara grinned back at her, "Good." She sat up and looked at John David. "Get over here please so I can suck your cock." He scooted a little closer as Sara stuck her behind in the air and went down on him. As much as things had changed, what hadn't changed was his wife's amazing ability to suck cock.

After a few minutes, Sara sat back up again. "Enter Emilee please." Emilee and John David looked questioning at Sara. They all knew the agreement that they had that John David would only enter Emilee if it was to get her pregnant. John David moved between Emilee's legs and looked down at her. He didn't want to make her uncomfortable, but she also said she trusted Sara's plan.

Emilee looked at John David with a gentle smile and nodded. He smiled back at her and slowly hovered above her growing belly and began to push inside her. She was tighter than Sara since they hadn't had sex in a while, but he was able to make it in after all the grinding the girls had done together.

Sara looked over John David's shoulder to see Emilee. "Are you ready?" Emilee looked nervous, but also trusted Sara and nodded. Sara pulled back John David's hips, then when he felt her pubic hair on his behind, she moved her hips forward to press him back into Emilee.

A groan crossed Emilee's lips, but she looked past John David and up at Sara. "Good girl," said Sara and Emilee arched her back in response. Sara once again pulled back John David, this time keeping in contact with his behind the whole movement. That's how they kept going, in and out, in and out, nice and slowly with Sara in charge of the whole movement.

This was one of the hottest sex sessions they had ever had together. Both women looking at each other and John David just a cock for Sara to use and fuck her lover with. He was so overcome with what was happening, he had to warn them, "Girls, I can't do much more, I'm going to cum!"

Sara was panting behind him, "Do it John, cum inside her and make her feel it!"

John David lost control, he slid in and out quickly and few times, then violently lost his seed deep inside Emilee. He didn't want to squish her and fell to the side to give himself a rest from what had just transpired. That was an amazing feeling! One of the biggest rushes he had ever felt.

Emilee lay on the bed exhausted and Sara moved on top of her, careful not to crush the baby beneath her. "Are you ok my love?" Sara cooed.

Exhausted laughter came from Emilee, "Yes, yes I'm just fine. That was so intense! It felt like you were the one going inside me."

Sara giggled as she rubbed their noses together, "Well that was the plan so I'm glad it worked." The two women made out for a few minutes taking turns moaning into the cabin air. John David rolled to his side and watched the show, caressing both women lovingly everywhere he could reach them.

Slowly Sara moved between John David and Emilee, settling in and enjoying the feel of the two people she loved most in this world. John David brought her into his chest and hugged her tight, then moved one of his hands to his wife's pregnant belly. He wasn't sure what he had done to deserve these two wonderful women in his life, but he was so glad the three of them had Forever.

This is unfortunately where we will leave John David and his wives. We will see them again, just not as the main characters. I hope you've enjoyed reading this series! Get prepared to read a new one about their neighbors, Tommy, Lydia, and Hyacinth.

Posted Jan 8, 2026, 2:53 AM UTC

50
Loading comments…