How to cope with colour blindness and those damned Cisco LEDs

Apologies if this is the wrong subreddit for this type of question and please feel free to direct me to a more appropriate place.

I'm currently studying networking at college and at the stage of learning the different types of LEDS on Cisco switches (port status, duplex, speed etc). I'm having a bit of a panic moment as I realise the importance of distinguishing between amber and green (up until now I've been asking my fellow students). Unfortunately, thanks to my condition I have trouble telling said colours apart.

Is this something I should be worried when I eventually dive into a career in networking? For those who are colour-blind, how do you cope?

:edit: Thanks to everyone who have come up with some very good suggestions and for also reassuring me that it's not the end of the world.

Posted Nov 8, 2013, 8:08 PM UTC · edited

4446
IWillNotBeBrokenCCIE•

Use the CLI? The color coding is just displaying information which can be gathered elsewhere, such as speed and duplex. The most useful information (IMO) for when you're staring at a device is encoded in on/off states, such as connectivity and activity.

17
SlivilthOP•

Sure, that's helpful and I was hoping that's the case. Up until now I've only been using CLI but I was just wondering how important it is to distinguish between colours. Thanks, at least I can tell when an LED is on, off or blinking; that's a start.

1
[deleted]•

It's not important at all. Think about this: when you call the support center of a networking company for help with an issue someone remote is helping you out. They are often literally half a world away from the switch. They can't see any of the blinkenlights and yet are paid to troubleshoot the devices, and do so successfully.

Even on the campus I work on I can go weeks without seeing a switch or router other than the 8 porter on my desk, all while working on them via SSH.

Though - story time - a colleague was sick yesterday and I had to escort a vendor into the DC last night for fiber maintenance on the regional ring. It was sort of funny to watch the blinkenlights on a transport switch affected by it. They moved 36 strands splicing them onto a different entry into the DC, 4 of which were in use. Of course the two ports on the switch that were on that leg went dead immediately and the lights went off, but the fiber being moved was part of a long distance haul for ISP connectivity via BGP. Apparently they didn't bother to soft shut the connection before the maintenance window so it was kinda cute that I was able to see BGP timers in action - the upstream was still sending a lot of data so the port LEDs that way were blinking like crazy for about 90 seconds receiving, and then just sat at a solid green after the BGP session timed out and the link stopped being used. Cute, but ultimately not also not very useful or interesting.

13
n0ah_fense•

Turn on BFD and lower that switchover time!

1
[deleted]•

Not my BGP session on either side. I'm just transporting it for a peer institution to get east bound I2/I1 access for them - we're bridging traffic between two regional networks for them. It's also considerably more than one link between the two routed end points so there'd have to be a minimum of 5 BFD sessions I'm aware of. It's two DWM rings bridged by direct fiber, basically.

[peer]-[region A fiber ring]-[my switch 1]-[my switch 2]-[region B fiber ring]-[peer]
1
kevlarcupid•

It's helpful to recognize status at a glance, but the LEDs don't tell you anything the CLI won't.

1
qnxb•

You want something like a Seekey. It's a pair of red and green colored (and differently shaped to help you tell them apart) filters you can alternately put over the LEDs to help differentiate.

6
beepee123•

That's actually really clever, and would solve the OP's problem. Though, along with what the other posts say, indistinguishable blinkenlights are only a mild inconvenience and should not prevent anyone from pursuing a career in networking.

2
SlivilthOP•

Thanks, I hadn't heard of this. I'll look into it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•

I was thinking you could do this, now I feel like Dilbert. All my good ideas are stolen!

1
frojoe27•

There must exist some app that lets you point your phone camera at something and it changes the colors around so colorblind people can differentiate. If not that would be super easy to make no?

5
SlivilthOP•

There are and the one that worked was decent enough so long as there was good ambient light but the Seekey that's been mentioned a couple of times might be the trick.

1
MaNiFeX.:|:.:|:.•

Oh man. No way around this, I fear, other than CLI. My sysadmin was working with me once. I asked him whether the port turned green, and he said, "There's different colors?" I remembered he was color blind, and I realized that he couldn't differentiate.

I also taught a blind intern to do both cabling and programming of switches... Nobody else on campus would hire him. I knew I was up for the challenge, and it paid off big time for me. I think I learned more about networking than he did that summer.

5
dragonEyedrops•

awesome that you did something like this!

1
MaNiFeX.:|:.:|:.•

Yeah, that's one thing in life I felt really good about doing. Like most of my interactions with people, I don't judge. I just treated him like a normal guy and if there were bumps along the way, we figured out a way around them.

What hurt me the most was watching others just assume he couldn't do something because of a lack of sight. He has a brilliant physics and CS mind, but got so frustrated. I would watch people scatter when they saw him using a walking stick... not to get out of his way, but seemed actually uncomfortable to be around him.

I don't know... maybe people just don't cope well with different.

2
asdlkf•

Do you have an iphone or android?

Put your camera into "negative" mode, so you see the "negative" image in real time:

http://imgur.com/a/w0QpU

5
recourse9•

Dude that will help me so much. So green is the brighter one?

1
AthegonField Network Engineer•

1, 2, and 4 are amber in that picture. the rest are green.

Those of us with regular color vision see the negative as blue and purple, respectively.

1
avatar307•

Myself and the other tech who handle all the fiber testing/troubleshooting are both colorblind. Him red, myself green. Using deductive reasoning and putting all the strands on white paper, you can figure out the colors.

However, things like amber/green LEDs or seeing orange paint on green grass are a bit more impossible.

How do I cope? I bring along a non-colorblind lackey, point at the lights and say "does that look amber or green to you?"

If you are connected via a console cable or telnet/SSH - you know way more than what the color of the light is going to tell you. The only time the lights matter are when something is screwed up. That's when someone saying "wait - I think these lights are all amber" will remind you "oh shit - did I allow the VLAN on trunk port?"

3
SlivilthOP•

At the moment I do have lackeys but they don't know it. Indeed, up until this moment I've never taken notice of the lights other than 'is there a connection?' but at some point I'm sure there will be an occasion where it could be really handy.

1
MaxQ•

I am not colorblind myself so can't say with certainty, but it's possible a smartphone app like this would be helpful: http://dankaminsky.com/2010/12/15/dankam/

3
SlivilthOP•

Tried this but keeps crashing on the One X. I tried another and appears to work fine however needs good lighting in the room for it to be effective.

1
pt4117•

I can't tell you the last time I needed to see an indicator light for my job. I think the only time it was actually helpful was when I walked past a switch and noticed an port blinking orange when they should have all been green.

3
Chooquaeno•

Some coloured translucent filters, credit card sized in your wallet would be a low resource solution.

3
DerHelm•

Have you tried getting a colored gelatin filter and seeing if you can shift the colors to something more distinguishable? No idea if it's possible, but if it is all you have to do is label the filter to know what you are looking at.

EDIT: forget an a

2
AvoidanceAddict•

I tend to use the CLI anyhow. It's rare for me to be looking at the status of the switchport and not need to have the CLI readily available if I need to make a modification. I rarely use the lights other than to tell if the port is up or not. Some switches have toggles that let you switch between link status, speed/duplex status, etc. Like others have mentioned, you can get all of this from the CLI.

The only instance I can really think of where differentiating green/amber has been useful to me is when a port isn't configured for portfast and it is negotiating with spanning tree. It's amber in the interim to tell you there's a link, and then it turns green when the port is actually active. But that's only going to happen within the first minute of the link being up, so as long as you're cognizant of that, then no problem. I wouldn't sweat it if I were you, but it's a good question nonetheless.

2
nofCCNAin't•

Yeah, but (some?) Cisco switches use amber for disabled, green for up, and off for down (but not disabled). Noticed this yesterday and actually wondered how colorblind people cope...then I just went back to the console session I was using.

1
FOOLS_GOLDRFC2544 Dude•

I'm colorblind and i've never had an issue outside of making cables (early years) or reading certain graphs.

2
SkilldibopNeed a bigger house to fit my lab in...•

Use only sonicwall firewalls, BT Homehubs and Linksys later generation WRT routers, barracuda antispam boxes. They have blue activity lights.

You'll love Meru Access points too, they use 8 colour status LEDs :D

2
from_the_sidelinesin ur subnetz, balancing ur wrkldz•

they use 8 colour status LEDs

 # service disco
1
SkilldibopNeed a bigger house to fit my lab in...•

haha, quite :)

1
AthegonField Network Engineer•

Cisco APs are reasonably colorful too. Especially when you put it into ID mode.

1
kidn3ys•

I recently worked with a gentlemen that was colorblind. The only problem we really ran into was when we were troubleshooting APs and weren't getting much from the switch. We finally realized something was up when the AP cycled through all the LED colors and he mentioned "purple."

2
JRHelgeson•

Carry a green light filter with you, like out of a lens of a 3D movie goggles and put it in front of the light. If the light doesn't change color, it is green. If it changes color, it is amber. (I just realized 3d glasses are red & blue - but you get the point).

2
atarifan2600•

I wouldn't worry about it. CLI and coworkers go a long way. Honestly,working with a colorblind friend makes me feel badly about all the poorly color-coded crappy Visios and excel spreadsheets I pump out.

2
[deleted]•

I am pretty badly colorblind but can identify a color much easier when comparing it side-by-side with something else.

See if holding up a white business card or a color from the edge of a credit card or something right next to the LED gives enough contrast so you can identify the different colors.

I have even used this technique when I have had to punch down multi-pair telecom cables with all the color shades.. I have to order them side-by-side as "most blue, slightly less blue, 3rd least blue blue, almost not blue.." etc to figure the pairing out. It's pretty ridiculous but the only way I can tell there's a difference

2
[deleted]•

Use light filters. Get an amber filter and a green filter, label them and use them to determine the color of the light. E.g., if you put the amber over the light and can still see the light, then it's amber, etc.

2
ratrl3•

I don't think the colour of the status lights ever came up as a big thing in the course or as part of any work. I think we had a short discussion in class about what the different colours and LEDs mean, and then moved on.

While it may be a nuisance, if after a few minutes a port (for example) doesn't work as expected and you're unsure of the colour of the LED then you can always fall back on the CLI to find out what's happening.

2
oregonjake12k users/24 wan sites/10k+ devices•

I use a color blindness app. ColoredEye on iOS and What Color? on Android. Or I just ask someone standing nearby. I have no shame.

2