Harry Potter Arcade - Shaker?

Anyone got an HP Arcade edition, played without the shaker first and then added one?

I know that CE and Wizard owners will tell me how much I need it, etc, etc… but the fact is that you never played without one so you can’t compare how much it adds to the game or if you could live without it. I am looking for those who played without a shaker and then with one. How much did it add to the game? Was it well integrated?

Personally, I love shaker motors on Jaws and Godzilla, but don’t like it on Foo Fighters (just an example). And I don’t think every game needs one, it needs to “work” with the game and make sense. Not just shake for the sake of shaking! Thanks for your valuable input!!!