BPT to NY Penn Advice

Facing a bit of a dilemma on what I should do for a trip next Saturday and looking for advice. I’m catching an Amtrak out of Bridgeport, CT to Penn Station (NYC) to make a connection down to Orlando, FL. I have a train booked for 7:56 AM and 10:50 AM. If I take the first time slot, I’ll be in Moynihan for a few hours waiting for the transfer. If I take the second timed train, I’m worried that I could potentially miss my connection as the connection would be 2 hours baring any delays. Does anyone that has experience with this route have any advice? Thank you!