"Member Since" for long-term card holders?
Just out of curiosity, what does your latest card say if you've had various cards through the years?
Despite AmEx thanking me for being a member since 1999, my Platinum Card says Member Since 24". I was chatting about something else and asked if that could be updated, for the next time I get a renewed card (not asking for one now).
The agent insisted that "Member Since" was not the "thank you for being a member since.." date, but when I applied for this card. "Just like your EveryDay card says Member Since 2018, when you applied for it."
I pulled out my EveryDay card and asked why it says "Member Since 99" if this was the case. And why the Companion Cards on the same Platinum Card says "Member Since 18"? He asked me where I was seeing this, to which I replied "I'm holding it in my hand".
After several minutes of silence, I just ended the chat. I'm not that worried about it.
But out of curiosity, does your card have the application year of that card, the date of your first AmEx card or, bizarrely, some other date?
Posted Jan 11, 2026, 5:52 PM UTC