Someone stole my airpod maxes

Hello, I accidentally left my airpod maxes at the RPAC gym.

I went to the front desk on 2 occasions and they told me they didn’t have the headphones in the lost and found. I checked the area where I left them a few of times.

I looked on find my and it said that they were around the stadium, somewhere I hadn’t been. I went to that they weren’t there.

I looked on the columbus.gov/police site, and it said I cannot report stolen property that is less than $300. However the gym told me that they can check the cameras and stuff once I have a police report filed.

what do I do?