H2C Error only printing from Handy

I got an H2C a few days ago and started by printing a few things from Handy. With some of the larger objects (poop buckets) the printer showed an error “right extrudor has anomalous readings” and stopped. Trying again, I get the same error.

However, the printer gets through auto bed leveling fine and I’ve printed the same object I was failing to print via Handy from Bambu Studio and I don’t get the message. I’ve also printed 5 other rather large objects this way without issue.

Is the sensor actually bad or is there some incompatibility printing on an H2C from Handy?