The Ghosts Of War - An important philosophic message to counter the flag-waving brainlessness of "Veterans Day"

Posted Nov 11, 2013, 8:54 PM UTC

307
Loco970•

Not an anarchist but this is a good statement.

4
LeehamenhouzenNon-specific Voluntarist•

I don't think a belief in anarchism was a pre-requisite but I'm glad you enjoyed it.

1
NielsioCarl Menger with a C•

It seems again that Molyneux can't decide what is important: effects (deaths, destruction, rising taxations and regulations, etc) or morality (whatever that may mean).

0
mattgrimesHater of Poor•

Why not both? As I understand Molyneux, arguing for morality is the only way to truly get things to change (and I'm inclined to agree) but that doesn't mean we just ignore the effects. If Government was all rainbows and buttsex I don't think anyone would care whether it was moral or not. IMO you can't get the message across without both a moral and effectual argument. The thing is, most everyone is aware of the effects of government, war, etc but no one considers the morality, and I think that is the point Molyneux is trying to get across.

But hey what do I know. I've only been an ancap for a few months. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

edit: sp

7
NielsioCarl Menger with a C•

Molyneux: "Consequentialist arguments don’t work.” -Source

If he thinks consequentialist arguments don't work, then he should stop talking about consequences. But time and again he keeps talking about consequences.

0
mattgrimesHater of Poor•

Studying for midterms right now so I will have to look in depth at your link later, but I, at least currently, really don't see an inconsistency (scanned the article and was previously aware of the Molyneux quotes).

Again, it's not that looking at the consequences are totally pointless. It's that you can't ONLY look at the consequences. I feel like it's kind of analogous to talking medicine but not exercising/eating/right. If you want people to be healthy, even with medicine people continue to get sicker. It is only in conjunction with, and supplementary (as opposed to being the primary mode of health) to a healthy lifestyle that medicine can be truly effective. Not the best analogy—it'd take some time to think of something better—but I think it works well enough.

I see no inconsistency in Molyneux's position (and I will check out your link) but hey if you do, I'm sure the guy would be open to hearing your criticisms. But even then, it's just the guy's method for trying to get people come to the rational conclusion that is a voluntary society. I think it warrants some respect just for reaching such a counter intuitive—in the face of all the propaganda shoved down our throats— conclusion. If you can think of a more consistent route to get us where we all want to go, then I'm all for it!

3
JeffreyRodriguezvancap•

You may not like the moralist argument, but death, destruction, and theft are well within that wheelhouse.

2