Taylor Sheridan missed the ultimate "Ace Card" with the Costner exit...
The biggest missed opportunity in TV history was not just replacing Kevin Costner with Bob Obenkirk the second he walked away.
Taylor Sheridan could have pulled the ultimate power move: the camera pans up in the Season 5 premiere, and it’s just Bob in a Stetson. No explanation, no "long-lost cousin" plot, just straight-up Obenkirk playing John Dutton like nothing happened.
The funniest part is that half the audience wouldn't even notice. He’s got the gravelly voice and the "don't mess with my land" stare down to a science.
Instead of fighting Market Equities with a rifle, he’d just find a zoning loophole from 1974 and settle the whole war with a class-action lawsuit and a handful of burner phones. We were truly robbed of "Better Call John."
Posted Jan 18, 2026, 10:27 PM UTC