27 Jan surely it’s my logic error but I can’t figure it out.

https://cluesbysam.com/s/help/79d5e4bbb266?state=jJg%3D-AAAAAA%3D%3D-060

per Maria, Kumar has 3 more innocent neighbors. per Jose, there are are either 1 or 3 innocents in C bordering Kumar. if it were 1, Kumar wouldn’t have 6 innocent neighbors. ergo, it must be all 3. but when I attempted to mark one innocent, I was refused.

where did I go wrong?