r/ffxiv•
Tharcide

SCH cleric on Wall = "Doesn't know how to play"

Posted Nov 16, 2013, 6:03 AM UTC

021
tief_tiefAerison Pendragon on Diabolos•

It is a very easy fight, but after 5 wipes you didn't say to yourself, "damn we're dying a lot maybe I should stop nuking and make sure we don't wipe again"?

14
throwawaygbhn•

could be this, could be that tank is bad and can't herd the bees well enough

could be bad DDs that can't dodge for their life

there's a lot of "could be"s

i run AK with a SCH friend a lot, fairy does a good job, with succor throw in to cancel out repel(yeah, the damage shield prevents the pushback effect if it negates the entire repel damage)

could be your DDs have bad rotations/damage

all in all, don't let this get to you

2
rockafella7[First] [Last] on [Server]•

Fairy should be able to solo heal Wall boss.

But as player, you should be able to figure out the potential of your group and adjust accordingly. If they need heals, even if it was unnecessary damage, it's still your priority to heal them.

6
Josh6889•

It's impossible to tell from this who's fault it was. If lack of heals is the reason the group was wiping, you probably should not of been dpsing. If bees weren't tanked, people got repelled off, etc, then I'd say you just had a terrible overall group

3
PixyRainDiabolos•

It depends on the group. If the group is wiping because they weren't getting enough heals then it's a no brainer, you should have stopped dps and healed. If you are dpsing and your group still gets bees it's a good indicator that your group isn't the best geared, so probably straight up healing would be better. Sure it will go slower, but wiping several times takes way longer than just playing it safe.

3
TharcideOP•

This brings up a question.

If the group kills the bees and doesn't attack wall, and just dodges and goes near boss for push....

Can the fight go on until the dungeon timer runs out or does the floor space completely disappear?

1
tief_tiefAerison Pendragon on Diabolos•

You get pushed into the rectangle floor aoe, and you'll most likely die.

3
PixyRainDiabolos•

Not sure, even in mostly lvl 45 af gear and gc weapons our group never had a problem killing the bees/wall in time to find out. I'd assume you would eventually run out of floor space to stand on and die anyway if you didn't kill it in time.

1
ThatPachi•

You should definitely be DPSing on wall (and anything else you can get away with it on). It's not clear why these wipes happened though. If you let people die to bees it is definitely on you to an extent (though if they're eating the aoes and not focusing them down if necessary it is their fault too). Not all groups are equipped to kill before they pop (or after/ignoring them), in these cases you definitely need to stop and heal.

2
NelugioNelugio Akimura [Shiva]•

hmm depends....

till bees you should be able to free dps since if ppl get hit by the purple shit on the ground its 100% their fault.

IF bees spawn you should switch back to heal tough in my opinion (its not really a dps race anyway this encounter and if you dps'd in the first phase there is kinda no way you would not meet it)

:)

2
ironorr44Leviathan•

When I'm doing Demon Wall with new people, I always focus on healing for at least the first few attempts. If you can't be certain they are going to reliably avoid the ground effects, it's probably best to stay in healing mode. Yes, if everyone does what they are supposed to, the damage they take should be minimal before the bees come out and you should be fine to dps. But, ultimately your job is to heal, so make sure that's definitely under control first.

2
TharcideOP•

Alright, thanks for comments.

I'm not sure if I'm happy about it though. Turns out I knew everything there was to know and executed it correctly, though I perhaps went out of cleric stance a few seconds late on of the attempts. and failed to do the dance right on most of them -.- it just takes practice.

I was in such a happy mood from finally downing titan without much fail at all from my part and then this guy tells me I don't know how to play SCH and I'll never make it as a healer. I'll ignore him and continue to improve. -.- I know I'm bad, and I like criticism but this one was a little hurtful

1
PixyRainDiabolos•

hehe don't let some random buttmunch get ya down. It just takes a little time to get to know the fights and figure out what your group is and is not capable of. Then you adjust your healing/dps to suit the group. It's also perfectly acceptable to just heal in a DF group. You joined as a healer, anything extra they get from you is just icing on the cake. :P

4
kniveswood•

It happens. I'm a healer on turn 5 and I still let tanks in dungeons die by accident from over-DPSing in cleric stance. It's the healer's job to adjust his dps/heals to suit the party. Good luck and continue improving!

1
Akava2005Akava Buvelle on Cactuar•

As a healer it all depends on the situation. Your primary job is to heal, simple as that. However, if you can manage to get damage in without putting your party at risk it is a great call. That being said, the moment your party starts to die off, you switch back to healing as a primary focus and sometimes drop damage completely.

If people were dying from taking tons of damage that was all avoidable that's bad on them, but if you were continuing to dps while this was happening, that's bad on you.

If they fell off the ledge, you can't heal that shit.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
hotprints•

One thing you can do to help which doesn't even require you to drop out of Cleric is to cast leeches on people if they do get hit by the purple line debuff (it's a pretty big slow debuff). I haven't healed with a new group and have only done AK 3-4 times (WP is just faster for farming myth). So I have yet to actually even see the bees on my scholar. Thanks to my status as a 3rd dps and leeches on the people who screw up so their dps isn't halved, we kill the boss before bees every time. If your group can't do that, i'd definately make an effort to to drop cleric stance in advance of the last repel and get everyone topped and have a succor thrown out before the repel. This gives you some leeway before having to heal when bees spawn so you don't immediately draw aggro. I would make dispels and healing first priority when bees are up. and then go back to cleric stance once they are down.

TLDR: Leeches is great. Cleric is no prob if bees aren't up. Consider not using Cleric at all while bees are up if you have problems.

1
TheBlackMage•

"I am confused. AM I not supposed to DPS?" In this case, you've got the wrong mindset.

A healer is always supposed to heal. Of course, Demon Wall is a dps race, so you should try to keep your basic dots up. But really, this is utterly unacceptable to refer to someone else. Sounds like a hardcore wow player transferred over. The other player is right, the tank should be tanking them to one side, which may be one of the problems.

You should always prioritize healing and removing debuffs, dps should be your third goal. Of course, if he's face tanking the aoe's, your screwed no matter what.

1
pretty_bakedkidz@gilgamesh•

He's just dumb. Obviously heals come first, but on such a simple fight, your fairy should be plenty of heals if people aren't sucking. I wouldn't worry about it too much.

-1
The-Phreak•

Tank was bad, you were good. The End

-2
brangor•

you sound terrible tbh

-6
TharcideOP•

You see that's not the problem here.

I am trying to understand the fight, and you aren't helping.

3