Help naming baby girl

me and my husband has a weird naming taste. we like timeless but also old and cool and chic type names. here’s what we have agreed on.

1. Leah Monroe (I like it but maybe too simple?)

2. Etta Monroe (I love Etta but I feel like it may have to be a nickname)

3. Indie Maren (We love indie but it definitely has to be a nickname..maybe full name indigo but is that weird?)

4. Ada Mae (my twin is Addison so I thought it would be nice to name after her! my only issue is my brothers ex had a dog named ada)

5. Mae/May Juliet (I love May/ Mae but I’m not sure about it as a first name)

we also kind of like Annabeth but with the Percy Jackson association (which isn’t bad) I’m not convinced.