Top 15 Pirate Ranking

1. Joyboy
2. Whitebeard/Roger/Shanks
3. Roger/Shanks/WB
4. Shanks/Roger/WB
5. Loki
6. Xebec
7. Kaido
8. Prime Mom
9. Shiki
10. Prime Rayleigh
11. Prime Gaban
12. Oden (could be 9)
13. Luffy/Blackbeard
14. Blackbeard/Luffy
15. Kuzan

Notes:

- I lean to Shanks over Roger and WB but I acknowledge factually it could go either way atm.
- Blackbeard is probably higher but we haven't seen his power on-screen yet, so this is essentially a Blackbeard lowball.
- The gap between 2 and 12 isn't that big, One Piece just has so many characters that even though there can be large gaps in lists doesn't mean the difference in power is large.
- I left out amped states.
- Shiki is there on vibes tbh. There's no canonical evidence that I am aware of that he is considered a Great Pirate which leads me to believe that he's slightly below the OG Yonko and Roger despite being highly competitive with those in that tier of power.