r/AskReddit•
endim

Why are commercial airlines, cargo ships, etc. still operated by on-board humans?

If commercial airliners and cargo ships did not have cockpits or any form of on-board human controls, they would be virtually un-hijackable. Certainly the technology is here to allow them to operate themselves and also to respond to emergency situations much better than human operators could.

In the case of commercial airlines, there would still need to be a method for flight controllers to redirect flights. There are various well-established methods known today to secure that communication, and obstruct jamming, and to mitigate under extreme attack situations. No more worry about hijackers. No more worry about people pointing lasers at cockpit windows. More room for passenger seating.

In the case of cargo ships, there is almost nothing a pirate could do. The engine room and other critical parts could be made very secured, and security systems could monitor for intruders and alert authorities. The ships could be designed without corridors, ladders, or other ways for humans to maneuver around on them. There would be very little a hijacker could do, except maybe cut open some shipping containers to find valuables they can load into their boat. Piracy would pretty much be eliminated.

Posted Nov 17, 2013, 7:24 PM UTC

04
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
endimOP•

This makes a lot of sense for commercial flights. It reminds me of a guy I knew a few years ago who was a commercial flight for a small commuter airline. On these small planes the passengers could see the pilot. He told me that there would be nothing to do and it would get excruciatingly monotonous because they have to sit there and act like they are actively flying the plane.

But it still leaves the question open for cargo ships.

1
matthank•

Planes still have to be landed by a person who can see the ground.

Still.

"Certainly the technology is here to allow them to operate themselves and also to respond to emergency situations much better than human operators could."

This assertion is untrue.

1
endimOP•

Sometimes pilots cannot see the ground and rely on instruments, and this can feed into the autopilot system details.

Well it is difficult to prove if the technology is there or not until somebody actually implements it. But I think it is there, and you disagree, so we'll just have to leave it at that.

1
kingsmuse•

Probably because the majority of people would never get on a drone commercial airliner.

I'm one of them... not happening

Certainly the technology is here to allow them to operate themselves and also to respond to emergency situations much better than human operators could.

No way.

1