I have an auto insurance question that I need to deal with

I had a 1999 Camry XLE and my last renewal was September 2025 for $286. After Thanksgiving, I got a 2003 Camry XLE and put it on the policy.

In January, I got rid of the '99, leaving me with only the 2003 Toyota Camry XLE

My renewal just came and it's for $458! For 6 months, liability only! And roadside, but I had roadside before too

I haven't moved, no violations, nothing has changed except the car. And it's still a 20+ year old Camry! Why did my insurance go up $172⁉️

And with no violations, isn't $458 HIGH? I don't currently have an agent, not really, some company is listed but I've never dealt with them