I actually like season 2 but I don't love it
This is just what I think so if you disagree, that's cool. It's always good to see others' perspectives. Sometimes it even helps me to see stuff I missed, but anyways!
I think Season 2 is a bit overhated. I do prefer Season 1 because of the plot and vibe (not including the 2019 plot because that plot was the only thing I hated), but I feel as though Season 2 is good. It has that old 30s vibe. It feels like it was made in that time period, and I actually dig the lighting and such. I think for what the season was going for, it fits perfectly.
But my thing is, there isn't really any character I love like I loved Mary Beth, Simone, Karl, and Mary Beth's neighbors, Mary and Sheila. They were the characters I loved (Simone took awhile to like), and the rest were either just there or I really hated.
But it was hard to latch onto characters in Season 2; I either tolerated or hated them. I liked that blond woman before that vet killed her though, and that PI. But that's kinda it. The characters were either unlikeable for being asses or plain stupid. And the pacing is slow at times, but I think Season 2 is ok. It's a season I waited a week for after watching Season 1, but it's good for what it is. I give it a 6/10.
Posted Feb 18, 2026, 2:28 AM UTC