40 [M4A] IL – I don’t know what to believe anymore.

I have to admit I’m completely lost about what’s actually true at this point. When my wife first began seeing other men, she told me she was going to be strict about always using condoms. Later she acknowledged that quite a few guys would try to slip the condom off during sex, and sometimes she literally had to wrestle them to get them to put a new one on because they were so deceptive about it.

After more time passed, she eventually let slip that in the heat of the moment the condoms could “just fly off” somehow. Then she actually got pregnant. When I pressed her about it, her explanation was that the condom “must have broken.” But on a different occasion, while I could literally watch her pausing and calculating, she said that, based on the timing, it could have been any one of three different men who got her pregnant.

So… does that mean three separate condoms magically broke? Or does it mean she was letting all of them go bare?