eshal vanilla or elysia vanilla?

Hii! I love kayali vanilla 28 SO much !! Ever since i got it as a bday gift i haven’t stopped wearing it. Unfortunately i don’t think i can afford to keep getting that one 😭 Ive heard eshal vanilla and elysia vanilla are close dupes !! They are both easily available for me so i was thinking to buy one of them. Which one is the better choice? I just wanna smell yummy on a budget🥹😭