Guys GTA4 is underrated

I know it was said a million times buy guys did you know GTA4 was dark and gritty? Like, super dark and stuff? GTA5 could NEVER get to the same level of grittiness! I mean like a story of a guy who fought wars and stuff and came to Liberty city to do exactly what he did back home instead of changing for the better like Florian I mean come on how can you not feel for him?! His past will never leave him and all that stuff! Like guys for real do you agree GTA4 is totally super duper underrated like we've been telling you a million times and that GTA5 is totally and really trash?