r/dirtypenpals•
sexylotad

[M4A] Unexpectedly cucked by my ex-girlfriend.

NSFW RP - Ongoing

We were together for a 3 years, and I was sure that during that whole time she had never found out about my secret fantasy of her fucking other people in front of me. I was absolutely sure of it. I used incognito, didn't talk to any of our friends about it, and so on. To me, there was no way she could know.

Until a year after we broke up, apparently, when her text came in.

Hey, so I have a proposition for you. We haven't spoken in a while, but my new guy has a fantasy that I know you share. He wants to fuck me in front of someone else. Basically a cuck scenario. I know you like that. Let me know.

The email caught me off guard and, honestly, embarrassed me a bit. How could she know? But, it also got me rock hard instantly, and took me back to the era of when we were together when it was all I could think about and all I could get off to.

My all time biggest fantasy was right in front of my face. Sure, we weren't together any more, but I still knew her and her body and her personality. How could I possibly say no?


Thanks for reading! I have a character in mind for me and for myself. I'm in my 30s, she's in her 20s.

I prefer to write on Discord if possible. I have a TON of fun kinks and few limits.

Let's chat and write something amazing!

Posted Feb 22, 2026, 4:59 PM UTC

10
Loading comments…