Visiting for 12 Days, Should I go for AirBnb or just book a rental off of Google?

I wishlisted some really good homes, wanted to know what's better locally? We don't need a hotel experience, just a flat with basic amenities.

Not sure if a vacation rental would feel like a "home" also a lot of them for some reason have exactly 8 reviews, all from bluepillow. That's why we moved to Airbnb as I trust it a bit better.

Any advice is helpful.