Thinking of switching from Garmin to Apple Watch – need advice (Ultra 2 vs Ultra 3 vs Series 11)

Hi everyone,

I currently use an iPhone 17 and a Garmin Forerunner 255 Music.
I love the Garmin for battery life, accuracy, and how reliable it is during workouts.

Now I’m considering moving to an Apple Watch, mainly for better integration with the iPhone and the extra health features. I’m just unsure which model makes the most sense for someone coming from Garmin.

These are the prices I’ve found:

Ultra 2: 599 €
Ultra 3: 839 €
Series 11 (46mm): 389 €

Coming from Garmin, I’m mostly looking for: • Good battery life (as good as possible)
• A watch that doesn’t scratch easily
• Solid heart rate accuracy
• Good for sleep tracking and everyday wear

Right now I’m thinking the Ultra 2 might be the best deal, since it’s titanium, has sapphire glass, better battery, and dual‑frequency GPS without costing as much as the Ultra 3. But I’m not sure if there’s any big reason to go for the newer model.

If anyone has moved from a Garmin Forerunner to an Apple Watch, I’d love to hear your experience.
Does the Ultra 2 make sense? Or should I spend more for the Ultra 3?
And is the Series 11 too basic for someone used to Garmin?

Thanks!