Honeymoon help! Club Wyndham resorts, non experienced travelers!

So basically, my fiancé and I will be getting married in October, and we’re starting to plan our honeymoon. We live in Ohio and are not able to travel often so I really want this to be a trip of a lifetime. But we simply don’t even know what to look for! All we know is we want to be near a beach and do some fun activities we’ve never tried before.

Originally we were thinking of doing a cruise, but the family I work for recently gave me their big book of Wyndham resorts, and told me to pick one in there and we’d only have to pay for transportation!

Now as someone who doesn’t travel much at all and has no experience with Club Wyndham, I have no clue where to look first, what resorts would be good for a romantic honeymoon, what would be a good place for that time of year, I have soo many questions😂

So far I’ve been looking at Hawaii, California(San Diego?), and of course Florida as some options, but would really appreciate any input, opinions, or advice!