Help me find the best Madden NFL game

Hey all! I'm in the process of trying to put together the five greatest Madden NFL games of all time. Using ChatGPT, I ended up with this list of games:

1. Madden NFL 2005
2. Madden NFL 2004
3. Madden NFL 07
4. Madden NFL 08
5. Madden NFL 12

It elaborated vaguely on each why, but tbh I trust your guy's input far more. Do you like this list? What would you change? Any games you would add/remove? And Why? Thanks for the help!