Goes Woes - Goes19 Trouble
Hey all! I am banging my head against a wall and just can't figure out how to make things work. I can't get a usable signal from GOES19 for the life of me. I'm appealing to the Reddit hive mind and u/creinemann for any help.
I have the Nooelec Satellite Mesh Antenna Bundle from Amazon:
Nooelect GOES Dish (aligned and LNB skewed to 22ish degrees, I'm in Kansas City)
SAWbird+ GOES LNA module (connected directly to the antenna)
NESDR SMArTee XTR (Have it currently directly connected to the LNA, but have tried other cables with no real effect)
RPI 5 8gb running GOESTools
MacBook running Satdump
A couple of days after I got started the NESDR SMArTee SDR just died - no signal from anything, anywhere on the bands. I got a replacement SMArTee SDR and was back in business, but I just can't get a good signal from GOES19. At first I was aiming the antenna via SSH on the Rpi - couldn't get the Vits below 600. To try and get a different view of what was happening, I took the Rpi out of the equation and just connected the SDR directly to my Mac running Satdump. I can't get above an average 2.8 SNR.
I have two main questions. Does the screenshot of Satdump look like I just have too much noise in my neighborhood? Plugged in directly or on via usb extension away from the antenna, the waterfall looks the same. I'm in the suburbs, but maybe this just isn't in the cards for me?
Second question, does the antenna boom look right? All of the pictures I see online have the brackets all the way at the end of the antenna boom - mine extends 1.5" beyond the bracket - it is 15.5 inches from the bracket to the top of the plastic piece that holds the reflector. Could I possibly have the wrong antenna boom?
Here's all of the things I've tried. Do you have any other ideas?
-Change all the cabling (No effect)
-Move the Rpi away from the SDR and LNR (helped take the vits down a bit)
-Added a spacer (3mm spacer seems to improve the SNR from 2.1 to about 2.8)
-Flipped the reflector (made things worse)
-Changed the shape of the reflector (some effect, but not substantial)
-Flipped the dish 90 degrees like Carl recommends (lost all signal)
-Moved the location of the antenna around my house (improved SNR from 2.1 to about 2.8)
-Replaced the SDR and LNA modules (Helped some, but I'm still maxed at 2.8 SNR and 500 vits)
-Tried just the SDR without the LNA module (lost all signal)
-Ferrite beads on everything (no effect)
-Turned off all of the breakers in my house (no effect)
Thank you for any help or advice you might have! I feel like I have tried everything and read everything there is to read on the internet, but just can't pull a good signal.
Posted Mar 9, 2026, 5:00 AM UTC