The phantom hoodie?

If you see a girl twice and slept together, she takes your favorite hoodie home- but then it doesn’t work out, and she doesn’t want to see you again (which is completely fair!). You kind of want the hoodie back, and she say you can come pick it up. Am I crazy for thinking she should be the one delivering it? I mean, she took it home with my “permission” and I could imagine picking it up if I was the one to break things off, but I’m not. Unreasonable or not?