[M4F] Critical Role - Defeated & Bred...

NSFW

Critical Role has quite an array of beauties, putting themselves into risky situations in a fantasy setting. Why not explore a situation where one or more of them ends up getting in over her head, and finding out what the consequences of a defeat might be?

#Vex, Keyleth and the Bandit(s)

Travel through Exandria was a perilous thing, for most people. But powerful adventurers? There was nothing to worry about there. The regular bandits and mercenaries that threatened merchants and caravan guards could not truly be a threat to Vex and Keyleth.

Besides, it would be a simple trip from one city to the next town over. What could go wrong?

It would not take long for that overconfidence to rear its head. Regular bandits getting the jump on them, getting in close to Vex to overpower the ranger physically, another slipping a magic-suppressing collar around Keyleth's throat before the druid could call upon the powers of nature to provide victory. Perhaps just a lucky ambush, or perhaps deliberate... But in either case, leading to the pair of them collared and chained, stumbling behind a new owner as they get led to their new life...

#Vox Machina's Mistake

How to investigate a reclusive noble? For Vox Machina, it seemed a simple option. Most of the group would go in openly, attending a feast - and then deliberately draw the attention of the guards. That would leave plenty of opening for Vax to slip in through a back door, look through the doubtless incriminating possessions in this castle, and then slip away by the time the party was thrown out. Nice and simple.

Unfortunately, running into such a plan without refinement... had repercussions. More guards than expected, for instance - Vax running into a trap when he thought the coast was clear. And local authorities that were in bed with this traitorous noble, for the other - so being thrown out was not quite what was the case for the suspected thieves.

Instead, they would be split up. The men tossed into cells, to be dealt with later - or perhaps even released. But for Keyleth and Vex? Personal interrogations from the noble they'd been against, as well as the town's captain of the guard awaited...

#Jester and the Innkeeper

It's not easy traveling, and in a small town with a festival going on, finding somewhere to sleep becomes surprisingly difficult. With rain falling, a poor blue tiefling might be particularly desperate to find somewhere warm and dry to spend the night. Of course, she wouldn't be the only one doing so - and the local inn would find itself unsurprisingly out of beds, save for one option. The innkeeper offering to share his own with Jester.

But that's better than sleeping in the cold and rainy night, wouldn't it? And would she realize just what she might be in store for the night...

#The Ruby's Conquest

As the most prized 'courtesan' on the menagerie coast, Marion would have her pick of clients. Picking and choosing who she would... entertain would be a favor in its own right - and part of what would keep the beautiful tiefling safe, by not even bothering to be alone with particularly annoying men. Rejecting them might even be a perk of her position - watching an arrogant young noble sputter at being told 'No', or satisfaction at putting down some slaver.

But that could lead to potential danger - rich, powerful men that wouldn't want to let a rejection sit around. And Marion's political involvements would leave an opening - as would her well known residence. Both prime for potential blackmail, or for good old fashioned breaking and entering. Or perhaps even deception - arranging for an evening of 'companionship' under a false name, and fully intending to push further than her usual limits. One way or the other, Marion would be remembering this for a long time - either finding herself warming his bed from that day onwards, or just being left behind with a parting gift filling her womb, and a reminder to not be so presumptuous in the future..

This could incorporate Jester quite easily, as well - after all, if she happened to be around her mother's house, she'd make for quite a tempting target...


If you'd prefer another critical role character getting put into a fun situation, or some other setup, let me know as well - I'm happy to hear your thoughts! Or if you're interested, Baldur's Gate could also make for some fun characters to see get in over their heads...

Posted Mar 14, 2026, 12:27 AM UTC

10
Loading comments…