The show told us this, but I’m sorry I just don’t buy it ( Spoilers for the final)

John, being the “righteous” man who supposedly didn’t torture souls in hell? Seriously? The angry, vengeful child abuser who has no problem belittling his own kids—the man that even demons are nicer than? You expect me to believe he didn’t torture others? Knowing John, he probably enjoyed it.

And then there’s Cas, telling Dean that he’s the “most selfless, most loving human being” he’s ever known—after Dean pulled a gun on Sam and said he would trade everyone and everything just to kill Chuck, and then admitting all he wanted was to be able to kill someone after not being able to get to Chuck when he went after Billie moments before this confession.