Early 30s Girls Trip to Ibiza - where to stay?

Four of us (early 30s, mix of married and single) are doing 5 nights in Ibiza this summer. We want a balance of proper nights out, relaxed beach days and a bit of exploring — not a full-on party holiday but we definitely want to experience the club scene. We have 2 planned big nights out and flexibility for the rest. We’ll have a rental car, but we’re conscious that drinking and driving obviously don’t mix, so we’d be relying on taxis for nights out.

Where we’ve landed so far:

We love the look of Talamanca and Old Town (Dalt Vila) — great location, walkable, character — but options are slim. We’ve found a really nice villa in Sant Gertrudis in the middle of the island that ticks all the boxes aesthetically.

Our main questions:

1. Is Sant Gertrudis too remote for a group like ours? We don’t mind driving during the day but are worried about taxi availability/cost for nights out, especially back from clubs like Pacha or Amnesia at 4am.

2. For those who’ve stayed centrally (Talamanca, Ibiza Town, Marina Botafoch area) — was the location worth the trade-off on accommodation quality?

3. Any hidden gem areas we might be overlooking?

Would really appreciate any firsthand advice — especially from anyone who’s navigated the taxi situation after a big night!