March 14 - having problems near the end

https://cluesbysam.com/s/help/677a3a83141b?state=eZeg-BAQAAAAACBgAAUVYAEgAAAAAUAAQ%3D-061

Why can't I put Isaac to be criminal? Andre and Hazel must be either both criminals or both innocents, so because of Chase's clue, Isaac should be a criminal. What am I missing?