birthday gift for bf

hi! i'm thinking of what to get my bf for his birthday. it's the first one we're celebrating together so there's a lot of pressure. i'm taking him out for dinner as well so budget is max $300. i know what he likes but it's hard for me to get gifts because i overthink and i'm scared that he won't like it.

right now, the things i know that he's mentioned wanting are a pocket organizer (aka flat wallet), a cologne that he really liked at sephora, or a nice jacket. his interests are gaming, cars, anime, and fashion. i think im leaning towards the wallet but i don't know if that's good enough for a gift.

any recs are helpful! thank you:)