Would you rather?: 2 DPADs or 2 sets of face buttons.

Would you rather replace the face buttons (ABXY) with another DPAD, or replace the DPAD with another set of ABXY style face buttons. (either symmetric or asymmetric style controller) Why?

With an increasing number of games using the joysticks over the DPAD for movement, the DPAD is often treated the same as the face buttons for actions.

For those who use claw grip, have you tried claw grip on the left hand? How did that work?