We can have a billion tier lists, but the ladder will define what's good and what's not

After you get to 2k+ points in this game, the points gained per win and loss becomes skewed towards loss. Basically, it gets to a point where losses lose you 2x more points than wins. And then 3x more points lost then won, etc. It gets harder and harder to climb, hence why actually getting to 3,000+ on a cookie is a big deal for the most part(some cookies are amazing in niche modes). At 3K, I've been hearing that you have to win 4x times to climb. The only way to arguably achieve that on a mass scale would be either a bunch of skilled players play a certain cookie, or a cookie is broken. The only exception being certain modes being abused for free points. So by the time next week rolls around, I'm pretty sure we'll see an extremely clear list of which cookies are insanely broken, and what's not.